What It’s Like Being the Person Who Has to Fire an Influencer

You’d think telling someone they just scored a free trip to Tulum or a six-figure collab would be the most dramatic part of influencer marketing. It’s not.

What It’s Like Being the Person Who Has to Fire an Influencer

You’d think telling someone they just scored a free trip to Tulum or a six-figure collab would be the most dramatic part of influencer marketing. It’s not.

You’d think telling someone they just scored a free trip to Tulum or a six-figure collab would be the most dramatic part of influencer marketing.

It’s not.

It’s the call where you say, “We need to pull the plug.”

If you’ve never had to drop an influencer mid-campaign — or worse, post-launch — you’re either very lucky or very new. Because sooner or later, every brand or agency finds themselves here: scrambling through screenshots, chasing down PR, and crafting a breakup message that somehow says “This is business, not personal” while also screaming “WTF were you thinking?”

When the Vibes Go Bad

Influencer “firings” don’t happen in a vacuum. They happen after the vibes shift — fast. Maybe it’s a political post that crosses a line. Maybe it’s new allegations. Maybe it’s a resurfaced TikTok that makes your legal team sweat.

Whatever the trigger, someone (probably you) has to decide: Is this salvageable? Or is this a cut-ties moment?

And that’s when the fun begins.

Step 1: Rewatch the Offending Content 87 Times

You’re not obsessing — you’re “gathering context.” You’re checking tone, timing, comment section chaos, and anything else that might change how bad this looks to the public. Spoiler: it never looks better the second time.

Step 2: Alert the Internal Cavalry

Legal. Comms. Client. Your boss. Your boss’s boss. The group chat. The Slack thread. The burner account you made for lurk-only research. Everyone’s about to get involved — and nobody agrees on the right move.

Some want to quietly end the relationship. Some want to blast a statement. Some want to wait and see. And you? You’re just trying to keep the brand out of a viral apology video.

Step 3: Make the Call

This is the hardest part. Because most influencers aren’t villains. They’re human. They make mistakes. Sometimes they’re open to feedback. Sometimes they’re just not a fit anymore.

And sometimes, you’re firing someone who didn’t even know they crossed a line.

You prep the call. You draft the email. You practice your “we appreciate your creativity” speech. And then you hit send or dial the number — knowing full well it might end with a polite “thanks” or a full-blown social media blowup.

The Fallout

Best-case scenario? It’s quiet. Nobody notices. The post disappears. The campaign moves on.

Worst case? You’re dealing with subtweets, angry fans, and a Reddit thread titled “Brand X Canceled Me for Having Opinions.”

Either way, your team’s back in damage control mode.

There’s a Better Way

At VwD, we built our platform to help you avoid the dramatic exits. Our tools surface risks before a contract is signed, flag problematic content in real time, and give you the context you need to make informed, defensible calls.

Influencers are a brand extension — and managing that relationship takes more than vibes and follower counts. It takes data, context, and a platform that’s actually watching the whole timeline, not just the highlight reel.

Let’s make “firing” a rare exception — not the plan B.

👉 Request a demo

#InfluencerMarketing #BrandSafety #CreatorEconomy #SocialMediaRisk #InfluencerCampaigns #MarketingOps #BrandReputation #DigitalRiskManagement #VettingCreators #PRFails #CancelCulturePrep #MarketingTools #VwD

Back to VwD Pulse